Showing posts with label FOC08. Show all posts
Showing posts with label FOC08. Show all posts

Monday, February 23, 2009

un-course

I would like to see more un-courses. I like to learn in a group. It doesn't have to be taught or even highly organized. Someone has to get it started, and maybe do a re-cap. The topic has to be interesting or specific enough to attract a critical mass. But other than that, that is plenty to provide a satisfying and rewarding learning experience. That's an "un-course".

FOC08 Facilitating Online Communities and CCK08 Connectivism and Connected Knowledge courses were great. They both had hard-working leaders who added a lot of value - course outline, readings, discussion set-up, as well as some other key components, like promotion and directing traffic and modeling communication at the kick-off.

If CCK08 and FOC08 are any example, having very large numbers of interested participants and a few vocal ones help enormously. It seems that there are many more lurkes than regular contributors, and the numbers decline over time.

A mechanism for regular updates helps - subscriptions, automatic aggregation of posts, discussion digests emails provide reminders to participants. That way participants can see what's going on and determine if they want to jump in or save the information for a schedule time later.

The Moodle course managements systems is flexible and accommodating. This WikiEducator Moodle installation is a great example. Once the course was added, I was free to set-up and use that "course" for this un-course. So far I am delighted with the results. Of course, it would be nice to have more participants. But considering the promotion was limited to the WikiEducator group email list with approximately 600 subscribers, this is a great response.

I'd like to see more un-courses under the WikiEducator banner. I hope that the WE administration will continue to support, and even expand and encourage these learning opportunities. By providing a home and a platform, WikiEducator can promote the teaching and learning side as well as the content creation side of open learning.

Do you have any un-course ideas? What learning support to you and your learners need that can be provided by Moodle? Are there any other facilitation tools that would be useful for un-courses in the future? Can WikiEducator play a bigger, more active role in promoting un-courses?

Monday, December 15, 2008

FOC08 course feedback

1. What were the most enjoyable aspects of this course?
The whole course was a really enjoyable experience. I sampled everything. I completed most of the "assignments" in some fashion.

2. What were the most challenging aspects of this course?
As my own courses are fully online, it was interesting and somewhat painful to watch Leigh deal with hundreds of participants who were "ramping up" to a pretty sophisticated learning environment. The settling-in period was challenging even for participants (including me) who needed to work out a comfortable personal learning environment while "drinking from the fire hose" of posts, messages and instructions coming in. Staying engaged for that many weeks was harder than I expected. However, it was all a valuable learning experience. The process is very interesting as both an observer and a participant.

3. Did the course meet your expectations? How or how not?
I wasn't sure what to expect, but there was lots to see and do. There wasn't anything that I hope to learn that wasn't addressed. That's good, or else I just don't know what else to ask.

4. What improvements would you suggest?

Outlining the environment setup as pre-work would have been helpful, sort of like the meet-in-the-lobby before the actual course / workshop begins. That would allow some people to get their blog and RSS feed going before the course with its "due dates" got the over-achievers all stressed out.

5. Any other comments?
Personally, I would have preferred a shorted session, but I know the course fits within the college schedule. When I was working on my Masters at California State University East Bay, the first few courses were offered as 6 week courses back-to-back within the 12 week semester. But that's just me.

Thanks, again for a really great opportunity to see some alternatives in online teaching and learning. I'd recommend this course to anyone interested in the subject.
..

Saturday, November 22, 2008

FOC08 thinking

It is interesting to see how the FOC08 community has mellowed. After the initial urgency and chaos, everyone settled down. Some got to work - they are enrolled in the course for credit so they are motivated. Some drifted off for a variety of reasons. And some of us hung out on the sidelines. It isn't lurking exactly, because I am participating in my own way.

The mini-conferences were an interesting opportunity for organizing online community events. I have enjoyed and learned from the facilitators blog postings. Congratulations to all - this is a remarkably difficult task. Even when the conferences didn't work out as hoped or expected, the mini-conferences were wonderful learning experiences.

The mini-conferences have some similarities with my online courses. Just getting a critical mass of participants can be challenging. Promotion, engagement, relevance are factors. Being subtle has no place in this. Getting "bums in seats" is difficult. Getting them to sit still long enough to become part of the community and the conference is even harder. Luck plays a surprisingly big role.

Community for credit (as in academic credit) is a significant factor. Is this actually a "community" as we understand it? I like to think it can be. The students that stick around for the full 12-week semester have a strong relationship to their classmates. It is more about them - student-to-student, than student-to-teacher or student-to-content. Yes, the course credit gives them an incentive to join and stay, but it doesn't require them to come together with sharing and caring. But it certainly helps provide continuity and a place for the community to grow.

From both the FOC08 and the CCK08 experiences, it is interesting to see how the large numbers of participants sort out - up-front active and highly visible to seldom seen but still there. I was particularly struck by the "attendance" at the CCK08 live meetings. From a "registered" population of over 2000 at the outset, 20-30 people participate in real-time. And I wondered why I had so much trouble getting 20 students in the same time zone to participate in synchronous events. It is about the laws of large numbers. I hadn't realized how large the base needed to be. The good attendance at FOC08 mini-conferences is remarkable, in this light.

I am involved in building and sustaining several communities - women with limited access to education, faculty with similar interests but no time to meet face-to-face any more, a local political group, a group of hikers, and scaling a leadership program beyond its physical limitations. In each case, an online representation is key to their existence. How participants participate may be different than originally envisioned - less direct feedback, delayed responses... But the value and the importance are still getting through. We leaders, organizers and facilitators will need to adjust, too.

..vt

Wednesday, November 12, 2008

CCK08 FOC08 - Tar Heel Reader

Everyone working with new readers needs to know about Tar Heel Reader.
Tar Heel Reader
Books for beginning readers of all ages

Welcome to the Tar Heel Reader, a collection of free, easy-to-read, and accessible books on a wide range of topics. Each book can be speech enabled and accessed using multiple interfaces (i.e. switches, alternative keyboards, touch screens, and dedicated AAC devices). The books may be downloaded as slide shows in PowerPoint, Impress, or Flash format.
http://tarheelreader.org/

I'm working with Grade 1-3 kids now. There are plenty of books already available. We will make more books together using the photos provided and our own word lists.

Tar Heel Reader is a wonderful resource for young adults. Lots of variety and many books are specifically provided for this age group. Having these kids author books as well as reading them is very engaging and challenging.

The authoring interface is easy to use and the resulting works are very "professional" looking. Beginning readers who build books will be very proud of their contributions. It is really exciting to know that people all over the world can read your book. If you and your learners are interested in building books as well as reading them, just request an invitation - this is how they are limiting spam and handling scaling the project.

This is what connectivism and online community mean to me.


Tuesday, October 28, 2008

FOC08 - Technology Supported Learning (TSL)

Technology Supported Learning (TSL)
http://www.wikieducator.org/User:Vtaylor/Open_TSL

This mini-conference is an opportunity to review Chickering & Gamson's Seven Principles for Good Practice in Undergraduate Education. It is also an opportunity to discuss online teaching and learning with colleagues everywhere.
  • tools and skills development to support learning through technology based on Chickering & Gamson's Seven Principles for Good Practice in Undergraduate Education. We provide the "guide on the side" and maximum flexibility to meet participants' needs within their time constraints.
  • using blogs, WikiEducator - outline reading, activities - blogs, discussions, email, collaborative writing projects
  • for faculty, instruction designers, teachers, facilitators, tutors, mentors

FOC08 - Community Leadership Development Mini-conference

FOC08 - Community Leadership Development
http://www.wikieducator.org/User:Vtaylor/Community_Leadership_Development
As an organizer I start from where the world is, as it is, not as I would like it to be .. Saul Alinsky
As organizers, where are community leaders starting? Please join me in exploring the development needs of community leaders. The "course" outline is intentionally light. The idea is to provide guidance without overloading the learner.

For the mini-conference this week and next, your participation will help
  • encourage discussion and feedback - need for a course like this, appropriate target audience, promotion for the project, adoption by communities, access issues
  • solicit recommendations for projects that could benefit from community service leadership provided by course participants
  • connect with colleagues, institutions and organization who are currently working in this area, or are interested in participating and/or partnering in the future
  • identify and review other resources that are applicable to the theory and practice of community service leadership and community leadership development.
This community leadership development program was envisioned as a very broad offering. I was always impressed by the youth leadership training programs for Boy Scouts. High schools and colleges are encouraging (even requiring) active learning and leadership in the community. Generation Ageless (aka Baby Boomers) are looking to add meaning to their free time through community leadership. Some of our original thinking was a follow-on to face-to-face workshops for women from all over the world. Focusing on community service supports a wide range of projects and leadership opportunities. Anyone and everyone can benefit.

Mini-conference Session 1. Community Leadership Development - Overview

Please look through the Community Leadership Development information
http://www.wikieducator.org/User:Vtaylor/Community_Leadership_Development
  • What were your first impressions?
  • Are you personally involved in community organizations?
  • Are you or someone you know or mentor in a leadership role?
  • Would you look online for some guidance for developing community leadership skills?
  • Would this work?
Then post your thoughts, questions and suggestions as comments here. If you would prefer to post to your own blog, please send a note and a link, so I can aggregate and respond.

Thanks so much for your interest.

Best regards,
..vt

Friday, October 10, 2008

FOC08 Community dynamics

I was recently involved in an interesting (read, troubling) exchange among community members that escalated to name calling and attributing sinister motives to one of the key contributors. I surprised myself by jumping in to defend the good guy, who is capable of handling the situation without my "help". As an experienced facilitator, this was a violation of Rule #1 - your job is to be objective, and the voice of reason, even if everyone else goes off the deep end.

I didn't have a problem the criticism, but I had had enough of the insentient troublemaking. In face-to-face situations, the individual would be asked to refrain from such behavior, and failing that, escorted to the door. Instead, it seems that after a couple of attempts by other bystanders to refocus the discussion, everyone else headed for the exits, not wishing to be a witness, much less a participant. This is how online communities come apart, and I am concerned that some irreparable damage has been done. It has certainly changed the tone of the conversation, from friendly to polite. Not the end of the earth, but disheartening, nonetheless.

So far, most of the FOC08 discussion has focused on the bright side of communities and their participants. Now, I'm reminded that there can be a dark side, or at least some bumpy bits. I'm trying to decide what this says about my role in the community, and the nature of that community and its members. I'm working on it...
.

Friday, September 26, 2008

FOC08 Wiki collaborators

I love wikis and Wikipedia. I come from a long line for curious engineers who think nothing of hopping up from the dinner table to consult the Encyclopedia Britannica for information or clarification for a discussion in progress. I'm just sorry my Dad didn't live to see it. I was an early contributor to WikiPedia - one of the benefits of living in Silicon Valley - this stuff comes up in meetings of the eLearning Forum (or whatever it was called back then ?? date).

As assignments in my online course, Computers and the Internet in Society, students participate in several wiki-based assignments.

  • Wikipedia - find a topic of interest to you or a controversial topic (looking for strengths / weaknesses in articles), check the history and discussion (active discussion and revision history are important sources of information), follow the links to the contributors to see their other work (many contributors do a lot of work, often on a wide range of topics), comment on the accuracy, credibility and utility of the articles selected
  • complete a community service learning project and document your work and learning as a wiki article
  • work collaboratively in groups of 3-5 to research and produce a wiki presentation for a topic that addresses issues of technology and society

Originally, we used the wiki within Moodle, which is a closed environment viewable only by registered students. The information is really good, so these projects are now being placed in public wikis. Students are reminded about the need for privacy - also a major topic within the course.

Getting students to write collaboratively is still a challenge. I often get one essay per person pasted together with a sentence or two of introduction and summary. A few groups have really worked to integrate the work more seamlessly. By applying a consistent style to the appearance and formatting, students take ownership of the entire project presentation. There isn't a lot of really collaborative writing yet. We are working on this...

Tuesday, September 23, 2008

CCK08 FOC08 Eureka - Thanks, JSB

Memo to: John Seely Brown

As a long-time fan, I have learned many things from you. Today is no exception. Following a trail of crumbs from CCK08 to ecological environment got me here Learning, Working & Playing in the Digital Age ..John Seely Brown 1999

So we now have navigation being coupled to, basically, discovery and discovery being coupled to bricolage but you don't dare build on whatever you discover unless you can make a judgment concerning its quality or trustworthiness. Thus navigation, discovery, borrowing and judgment all get wrapped up together, especially when the student is engaged in using or building something that he deems important. Judgment is inherently more critical than ever in order to become an effective digital bricoleur.

I think this is a good summary of the complexity of what we are wrestling with in Connectivism and "the new learning" (something like "the new math" for those old enough to remember that one).

How I got here... ecological environment - interesting, need for additional terms - niches, meaning cues, action traces ... interrelations between communities, the environment and the culture left there by people - the traces of meanings (Llora, Yasui, Welge & Goldberg, 2006) and the traces of activities... JSB link, lurk, try

Saturday, September 20, 2008

CCK08 comment on blog post / FOC08 open vs closed communities

Darn it. I see a really interesting partial post by Nellie on Generosity - someone I greatly admire and who's great effort in organizing the WikiEducator Council election should be recognized and celebrated. And, bang - sorry you can't read the whole post or add a comment.

This leads to some thinking, and I hope, some further discussion about making and breaking connections (CCK08). And open / closed communities (FOC08). What's in it for me? If I block comments utilizing the provided screening devices, then I don't have to deal with the spam and annoying poor connectivism hygiene of others.

In a community where the primary communication is via discussion forums, there is the problem of the Commons - in a large open discussion, everyone is a user or a guest and no one assumes responsible for the ongoing sustainability of the resource. They post what they want, even if it means others are turned off by the frequency and/or tone of their posting. We have seen this to some extent in the CCK08 course in the Moodle discussions. A more closely held, closed community is better at dealing with this format. All participants accept and share responsibility.

Well, yes but... Houshuang says "I really want my research to be available to everyone ... approval is taking too long, so I am also publishing the files here on my blog. ... Creative Commons BY license. I am eager that as many people as possible that would be interested in this topic are able to come across it, so feel free to share it with others that are interested. I am also very happy to receive feedback and other perspectives"

This may be representative of most blogging - intended as primary personal statements, observations and links to other information of interest. A community that is built around blogs can be very open and inclusive as each member controls their own space within the community. In FOC08 and the blogs associated with CCK08, the openness is clearly a benefit. There have been protests from the community when registration is required to view and/or comment on blog entries. Openness is not only desirable, but expected, at least among the blog commenting participants in CCK08.

Returning to Nellie's post on Generosity, I actually have a Ning account and reluctantly logged in to read the post and comment. I wouldn't do this for just anyone. Nellie is very special.

Wednesday, September 17, 2008

FOC08 / CCK08 double-dipping - Community Blogging

Stephen - again talks about Community Blogging. I read this article when it was first posted, but I didn't understand too much of it then. Little did I know, that it would be back. Thanks. I really enjoyed it this time, as I nod my head in agreement.

This week I have been in meetings and presentations about student civic engagement and community service learning. I was astonished how often the words "connections" and "networks" came up in the discussions. Although most references were more general, it was good to hear that there is an interest and awareness of these ideas in community colleges.

Thursday, September 11, 2008

FOC08 and Global Voices - Blogging Networks

FOC08 Looking for online community: Blog networks

The Wikipedia Blogosphere article points to specific examples. Global Voices Online's particular focus is on non-Western and underrepresented voices. Global Voices aggregates, curates, and amplifies the global conversation online – shining light on places and people other media often ignore.

To help contributors, Global Voices provides guidelines and encourages discussions on subjects that might not otherwise find readership. By aggregating and promoting these blogs, the issues get visibility that would be impossible for the individual. Providing community, support and promotion for these messages, many more readers are aware of the problems faced in other parts of the world, and can share and contribute to their solutions. The Global Voice blogging network is an inspiration and a resource to others.

Blogging network FOC08 There are many examples of links from FOC08 participants (Bee, Amy, Dolors, Daryl) to one another, and links to outside resources (World Cafe, art of hosting, A Group Is Its Own Worst Enemy, Marcel, Shelley, Wenger) with posts that expand, explain or contradict a discussion within the conversation in FOC08 blogosphere. Participants take responsibility for contributing with intra- and extra-FOC08 blogosphere references - nice give and take aspects to this form of community activity.

The facilitators set the process in motion with the overall course structure. The earliest course activities included creating a personal blog (Blogger, Wordpress, Posterous), providing the RSS feed link to the central participant list, setting up a feed reader (Netvibes, Bloglines, Google Reader), posting to the blog, commenting on the posting of others, posting follow-up summaries with links based on reading the posts of other participants. Although this was a new way of working for many participants, it has served well. The facilitator also modeled the expected behavior, posting to the course blog, posting comments, and highlighting examples of participants who demonstrated great networking.

Bloggers retain ownership of their participation in the community. This is very different that simply posting a reply in a more traditional threaded discussion. With blog features like tags and categories, the information is archived, searchable and retrievable. This adds to the permanence of the community. There is history. The identity and contribution of the participants are kept. The community knowledge base expands.

The technology tools to help create order and meaning from the apparent chaos are well established (social networking - Facebook, MySpace, LinkedIn), (social bookmarking - delicious, Digg), (blog rating and aggregating - Technorati, Wikio blog ranking) and new improved tools are being introduced (iLeonardo, iterasi).

Blogging networks are an important component of any community. Providing a focus and an aggregation of blogs by community members about community issues, the community is active, informs its membership, reflects on issues and dynamically formulates solutions. The community thrives and grows by giving everyone (non-members as well as members) an opportunity to participate and have a voice in the conversation.

Thursday, September 04, 2008

Alice.org - the 3D programming environment and community

FOC08 Looking for online community: Discussion forums

Great technology can make a huge difference to the community vitality. The task of facilitation changes dramatically when the underling software environment provides information that helps build and sustain the community. It doesn't eliminate or diminish the role of the facilitator, but it does change the nature of the role. More time can be devoted to high-order facilitation tasks when the technology is automatically taking care of basic administration functions, accumulating activity information, and providing direct feedback to the community about itself and its members.

Alice is an innovative 3D programming environment that makes it easy to create an animation for telling a story, playing an interactive game, or a video to share on the web. Alice is a teaching tool for introductory computing. It uses 3D graphics and a drag-and-drop interface to facilitate a more engaging, less frustrating first programming experience. This is a project of Carnegie Mellon University to explore alternatives to increase enrollments in computer science classes, especially by girls.

The Alice.org community includes current users of the software, teachers, students and others interested individuals. Where use of Alice is associated with a programming class, students and teacher participation in the community may be limited to the duration of the course session.


Alice community forums Currently Active Users: 42 (3 members and 39 guests) Threads: 1,559, Posts: 6,363, Members: 3,480

  • comprehensive FAQs
  • online form to email administrators
  • administrators, with online/offline status indicator
  • good forum search capability
  • membership restricted areas - calendar
  • registration - forum rules defined, agreement required
  • what's new tab
  • posts are viewable by guests
  • guests (nice word for non-members) Posting Rules You may not post new threads You may not post replies You may not post attachments You may not edit your posts BB code is On Smilies are On [IMG] code is On HTML code is Off
  • classes of members - junior (high school student), senior, administrator, member
  • number of posts - most post 834 (senior member), 10th highest 95 (including 1 of the administrators - third most posts, others all senior members), top 10 total post 2976 of 6363 total (47% of all posts), regular member with highest number of posts 49 posts 15th most
  • last post - today Sept 6, 2008, earliest post - July 2005
  • global participation - CMU is in Pittsburgh, PA, recent questions from Florida, Texas, Oklahoma, Canada, Portugal
  • forum very conducive to community - avatars, member stats and information including location, member type, number of postings, member since..
  • Lounge provided for off-topic posts
  • great newsletter
  • members are fielding questions, not just the administrators


Facilitation in the Alice Community Forum

  • not much formal facilitation beyond providing the environment and responding to Alice and forum technology questions
  • some invitations for suggestions and comment - new features, forum organization (gabe)
  • good quick response to most questions, several members (DrJim) are acting as facilitators as well as community members
  • a subgroup of users is working to generate additional interest in the Alice community

Some facilitation suggestions

  • use the What's new forum topic to recognize and promote the work of community members
  • promote the community beyond the community to schools offering Java and other programming languages
  • encourage the community to recruit and spread the word - this is a great tool for teaching and learning Object Oriented Programming (OOP) and could have even wider distribution
  • host an "event" to showcase the work of community members
  • encourage members to complete / expand or update their member profiles
  • suggest that members add a picture or avatar to their profiles
  • seed The Lounge forum with related timely topical questions for discussion
  • add a forum topic to collect links to references to Alice in publications, training materials,...
This is a very nice community for those using it. The technology for the forums promotes the sense of community and allows the facilitators to see and manage the interactions that enhance the community spirit. The infrastructure is in place to support a larger more diverse community. Facilitation efforts can be directed to recruiting new community members from other areas of education.

I wish them every success with the Alice 3D programming environment community and hope that it grows beyond their wildest dreams.

Thursday, August 21, 2008

What's it all about?

Good article about books vs. the Internet that makes a point that is relavent to the FOC08 Facilitating Online Communities discussion.

John Hagel says, "tacit knowledge will only flow through shared practice and the deep relationships that build up around shared practice. Some examples of shared practice can already be found on the Internet in such diverse arenas as open source software and online games like World of Warcraft. This is one more area that the Internet will likely evolve to support much more effectively in the years ahead."

Online communities and the technologies to support them are evolving. What we know today is rapidly changing. This will have a profound impact on the nature of online communities and how they are "facilitated" - assuming that's the right word for what we are doing.

Wednesday, August 13, 2008

More communities

I should have done this sooner - just look it up in Wikipedia. Or as Minhaaj reminded me - RTFM - Thanks.

From Wikipedia - entry for Community
In biological terms, a community is a group of interacting organisms sharing an environment. In human communities, intent, belief, resources, preferences, needs, risks, and a number of other conditions may be present and common, affecting the identity of the participants and their degree of cohesiveness.

In
The Different Drum: Community-Making and Peace, Scott Peck argues that the almost accidental sense of community that exists at times of crisis can be consciously built.

4. True community: the process of deep respect and true listening for the needs of the other people in this community. This stage Peck believes can only be described as "glory" and reflects a deep yearning in every human soul for compassionate understanding from one's fellows.

More recently Peck remarked that building a sense of community is easy but maintaining this sense of community is difficult in the modern world. Community building can use a wide variety of practices, ranging from simple events such as potlucks and small book clubs to larger–scale efforts such as mass festivals and construction projects that involve local participants rather than outside contractors.

We have all seen examples of instant community building in the wake of hurricanes, earthquakes, snow storms, and man-made disasters.

Saturday, August 09, 2008

What is an online community?

I'm working with several online communities. As I think about the assignments for the FOC08 course, these communities will provide the examples, active research opportunities and reflection observations. I'm a participant in Facilitating online communities community and the WikiEducator

community, and one of the "moderators" in our Moodle Users Group

  • Facilitating Online Communities course FOC - share interest in subject of facilitating online communities and participate in an online course to learn more individually and as part of the community of learners.
  • WikiEducator WE - broader group looking at creating and sharing open educational resources
  • DeAnza Catalyst Collaboration (Moodle Users) DCC - faculty and staff with access to Catalyst / Moodle interested in learning about and using it for teaching and learning, sharing local practices, relatively new small group within a large college

In the Groups and Networks video, Stephen Downes makes the distinction between a relatively closed group and an open network. Etienne Wenger describes Communities of Practice: Learning as a Social System defined by knowledge rather than by task, and exists because participation has value to its members. In the 12 Principles of Collaboration, groups of interest form within a community.

Okay, so where does this leave us? What's In It For Me? Participation in each of my three communities has value to me, personally and professionally.

  • who - early adopters, thought-leaders in each area are also participants, starting to figure out who some of the key contributors are in addition to Leigh and Bron
  • what - subject matter, knowledge and skills have direct applicability to teaching online college courses and facilitating faculty workshops. I'm in the moderately techie group in the FOC08 community. I have experience and interest in OER development in WikiEducator.
  • how - lively group discussions, first rate wiki content, links to resources that support and extend the knowledge base
  • when / where - anytime, anyplace via email, RSS reader

Anything missing that I care about?

  • potential - great potential for interesting and important contributions to the areas addressed
  • coalescing - all are very much in the formative stages and have yet to reach their full potential and/or a steady state
  • active - coming soon...

Assuming that any or all of these communities have merit and value, there are a number of questions that come to mind. Will these communities live up to their potential? Are there enough participants to keep them going? Is the value there for the participants? Will they attract and sustain new members? How big is big enough for the community to work and continue to provide value? What can be done proactively to ensure their continued success?

I'm looking forward to the postings of other FOC08 participants.

Monday, August 04, 2008

Herding cats

Getting started is always the hard part of organizing an online community. Everyone is coming with their own notion of WIIFM - What's In It For Me. Expectations and objectives may have been spelled out by the facilitators, but these may not mean the same thing to the community as expected. In a big group, the interested parties may not be representative of the intended audience. Add to this the huge range of online participation experiences and technology backgrounds.

Here are a couple of helpful ideas to understand the dynamics and prepare for dealing with these challenges.

All Things in Moderation in the 5 stage model for Running E-tivity plenaries puts forward the normal progression of building an online community that will work together collaboratively.

1. Access & Motivation
2. Socialisation
3. Information Exchange
4. Knowledge Construction - knowledge development, discussion activities and group dynamics
5. Development - reflection and group learning
Starting by requiring everyone to adopt three or four fairly sophisticated online environments is entirely appropriate if this would be routine for the target audience. It could be used as a gatekeeper exercise - if this isn't easy, then you might not be ready for what follows. Dealing with the folks who don't have the background will be time consuming at best, and frustrating, in most cases.

Providing an opportunity to simply access content and encourage participation through low-risk socialization helps establish a safe foundation for building community and exploring new technologies, social interactions and collaboration in an online environment.

Another consideration is an individual's "technoprofile" - the way people behave in social networking: creators, critics, collectors, joiners, spectators, inactives.
What you see may not be what you get. This set of descriptors nicely highlights the usual mix of participants in any community, online or face-to-face. In the online community, participants may adopt very different roles from their usual face-to-face ones. Shy students are fearless. Verbally chatty individuals may be poor typists and self-concious spellers. Large numbers of "lurkers" can go un-noticed. The intended audience may be put off by the "noise" of the folks asking all the questions or making comments that are well beyond the scope of the intended subject.

Making sure that the participants are all moving in the right general direction toward the formation of a community is like herding cats.

Real communities

Once upon a time there was a company called Real Communities (now Mongoose Technologies). They did some great work identifying and promoting online communities.

All communities, on or off the web, adhere to basic principles in order to thrive. Mongoose Technology codified these tenets into the 12 Principles of Collaboration which form the sociological basis of their product design.

The 12 Principles function as a hierarchy. The chief principle, Purpose, is supported by the other 11 principles - Identity, Reputation, Governance, Communications, Groups, Environment, Boundaries, Trust, Exchange, Expression and History.