Showing posts with label CCK08. Show all posts
Showing posts with label CCK08. Show all posts

Monday, February 23, 2009

un-course

I would like to see more un-courses. I like to learn in a group. It doesn't have to be taught or even highly organized. Someone has to get it started, and maybe do a re-cap. The topic has to be interesting or specific enough to attract a critical mass. But other than that, that is plenty to provide a satisfying and rewarding learning experience. That's an "un-course".

FOC08 Facilitating Online Communities and CCK08 Connectivism and Connected Knowledge courses were great. They both had hard-working leaders who added a lot of value - course outline, readings, discussion set-up, as well as some other key components, like promotion and directing traffic and modeling communication at the kick-off.

If CCK08 and FOC08 are any example, having very large numbers of interested participants and a few vocal ones help enormously. It seems that there are many more lurkes than regular contributors, and the numbers decline over time.

A mechanism for regular updates helps - subscriptions, automatic aggregation of posts, discussion digests emails provide reminders to participants. That way participants can see what's going on and determine if they want to jump in or save the information for a schedule time later.

The Moodle course managements systems is flexible and accommodating. This WikiEducator Moodle installation is a great example. Once the course was added, I was free to set-up and use that "course" for this un-course. So far I am delighted with the results. Of course, it would be nice to have more participants. But considering the promotion was limited to the WikiEducator group email list with approximately 600 subscribers, this is a great response.

I'd like to see more un-courses under the WikiEducator banner. I hope that the WE administration will continue to support, and even expand and encourage these learning opportunities. By providing a home and a platform, WikiEducator can promote the teaching and learning side as well as the content creation side of open learning.

Do you have any un-course ideas? What learning support to you and your learners need that can be provided by Moodle? Are there any other facilitation tools that would be useful for un-courses in the future? Can WikiEducator play a bigger, more active role in promoting un-courses?

Saturday, January 24, 2009

Never too much of a good thing

One of the assignments activities for my Computers and the Internet in Society class asks students to visit a social bookmarking site. Digg, Delicious are provided as examples. They are asked to comment on the experience. Did they have prior experience using social bookmarking?

I'm always surprised that this is new to college students, even ones living and working in the heart of Silicon Valley. This is a typical response.
I looked around read a few shocking/interesting articles and headed to the Technology topic where I read about companies like Digg, Mozilla, Microsoft and Apple. Make it stop! I'm addicted!! I went to Digg thinking it would be quick but it was one click after another. This site has a great compilation of interesting reads and is categorized by interests. I think social bookmarking peaked my interest because I am reading about stuff I wouldn't otherwise read --unless I went to that website directly. Also, it conserves a lot of time since these posts are rated, you can read what the majority finds most interesting first.
This is really reassuring. If we can provide the right combination of motivation and content, students can and do learn. They will spend the time on task to explore, examine and reflect. All I needed to do was set up a learning experience. I love the excitement expressed. I am extremely gratified and proud to be part of the process.

In a recent comment about Personal Learning Environments (PLEs), someone (perhaps Stephen Downes or someone he cited) reminded readers that PLEs still need direction and support - this is not just "throw 'm into the deep end of the pool". This got me thinking about my online course - Moodle, wikis, web research, web 2.0, images, media literacy, blogs, podcasts, virtual lectures, ePortfolios... This is definitely a Small Group Learning Environment (SGLE).

But does that qualify as a PLE for individual students in the class? I have decided that Yes, this is a pretty good approximation of a PLE. Students have a lot of flexibility within each assignment activity. Most assignments are submitted as posts to discussion forum topics so the entire class sees these. There is a lot of peer-to-peer sharing and learning going on. They get direction and support from me and other students. The good students tend to post early and often so they model best practices for the others to follow. Everyone learns a lot, especially me!

The biggest challenge has been refining the activities to encourage students to work this way. Each student's learning experience is similar but different. In the end, they all cover the material and meet or exceed the student learning outcomes defined. Students also say they have learned about learning and will take that away with them. This is very exciting for me, too.

Providing each student with a course-specific Personal Learning Environment is doable. It is a good start to helping all learners reach their full potentials in ways that are meaningful and interesting.
.

Saturday, November 29, 2008

CCK08 host with the most

I have been reading Stephen's http://halfanhour.blogspot.com/2008/11/future-of-online-learning-ten-years-on_16.html
He talks about the Triad - learner, host, provider model.

The notion of Host is helpful. Brings to mind the GOs at a fabulous ClubMed-like educational resort. You can work on some new skill or knowledge area like juggling, enjoy good food and new friends, or sit in the shade with a trashy beach book. The hosts are there to see that you are safe and happy, and as challenged as you want to be. But basically, it is up to you to do as much or as little as you please.

Capable hosts providing support and guidance for the learners' journey - here are the facilities, the resources, even the instructors if you need them. We would be happy to make suggestions as that is part of our service. These are all at your disposal for as long as you wish to stay.

Sage : Guide : Host - this works for me.
.

Thursday, November 27, 2008

CCK08 simply complex

Someone (sorry, don't remember who) was observing the tendency today to reduce important complex issues to a single point or sound bite. This got me thinking. The "sage on the stage" superseded by the "guide on the side" representing a pedagogical shift falls into that category.

The tag lines are easy to remember. But the messages and mental pictures associated with each are very powerful. This is a good thing, even if they grate on George and others who have been over-exposed to them. These taglines are really useful. Time and again, faculty new to the changes in teaching and learning "get it" when they are introduced to these catch phrases.

As these taglines are going to be around for a while longer, we need to expand the set to include one that succinctly captures the essence of Connectivism. What is a nice little tagline that has the power to conjure up the complex mental image of what Connectivism is?

In my mind's eye, I see the sage on the stage as some over-bearing expert going on about something that is important and not very interesting. The guide on the side is the enthusiastic supportive coach-like person who wants nothing more than for me to succeed at doing what the guide is good at. Well, these are MY visualizations after all.

For connectivism, no strong image pops into my head. Having one would make this all so much easier to explain. That necessitates reducing something complex to its simplest form, but provides a framework to build an understanding for this important set of ideas. It needs to be simple, yet complex, and it needs a cute title.

Any suggestions?
.

Wednesday, November 26, 2008

CCK08 Now that you asked..

The CCK08 MOOC experience has been fascinating - 2400 educators, academics and others all participating in a "course" expecting to learn something. I don't know what I expected to learn, but it sounded interesting. The facilitators, guest presenters and learners included the who's who of online teaching and learning. How bad could it be?

So here we are coming to the end of this great adventure, and we are asked for feedback. Lots of talk about metrics and qualitative evaluations, but what applies?

Well, it turns out, by my reckoning, just about everything. I hauled out my trusty Course Evaluation Checklist. If it is appropriate for guiding faculty participating in my Technology Supported Learning workshop, it should have the depth and breadth to assess the Connectivism course.

The checklist is actually two sets of questions to review undergraduate education courses and the technology used in their delivery.

Seven Principles for Good Practice in Undergraduate Education

All the questions could be answered with good examples from the CCK08 course. Everything was addressed in an exemplary fashion. I know you are supposed to find some areas where you, the reviewer, can make some constructive suggestions for improvement. Darn, I couldn't think of any. I'm sure there must be some, but nothing jumped out as an opportunity for teaching moment.


Learning Environment Technology Considerations

The second set of questions deals specifically with the use of technology in teaching and learning. If there are any weaknesses, they are in the basic assumptions behind the evaluation questions. Some of these notions are down-right quaint. The respect for course management is so last week.

So the Course Evaluation Checklist severed a useful purpose, just not what I expected. Instead of suggesting some areas of improvement for the CCK08 course, I have work to do. I need to go back and update the checklist and my faculty development workshop. I'm open to suggestions.
.

CCK08 every day in a letter...

Terry talks about in-depth processing in networks, and about lack the energy, time and commitment to dig deeply in his networked connections.
In a group I feel more responsible for the other group members and open myself to challenging emotional and cognitive debate, support and nurturing - all of which may cost me an investment of time, energy and emotional commitment

I have relied on the daily CCK08 letters to stay current and engaged. But the down-side is the shift to "group mode" - someone - Stephen and George are taking care of me. It isn't like they don't have tons of other stuff to do.

This is something I struggle with as an instructor and as a student/participant. How much responsibility does the learner have for their own learning? How much guidance should be provided? And by whom? What is the expectation of the guider for how this information will be used? Does that expectation somehow define the boundary between a group and a network?
.

Tuesday, November 25, 2008

CCK08 a gift horse

I agree with Matthias that an indirect effect leads to better success in learning than direct, goal-directed attempts to control the outcomes. Perhaps we are just slightly ahead of our time. We "get it" but I am very concerned by my students' apparent inability or unwillingness to engage in learning beyond what is explicitly codified. Giving them permission and encouragement to explore and develop their own connections has not been met with the wild enthusiasm that I expected. This is going to be challenging.

Nature or nurture? Structural preferences? What can I put in place to help my chickadees move toward this wide open space that is theirs to discover and enjoy for the rest of their lives?

Resonance is an interesting concept. Whether it is a physical structural preference for threaded discussions and blogs, or a range of ideas or just writing style, inclusion of white-space, font selection and word choice in a catchy blog post title, some work products of other CCK08 participants just jump out and grab my attention. Before I know it, I'm connected to something old, something new and/or something borrowed. The give-and-take generated from the posts, comments, replies and feedback is exciting as well as informative. This is so multi-faceted that determining how this happens is way beyond me. Suffice to say it is a fascinating topic in itself.

I would have to say that, at this time, I'm firmly in the external devices as auxiliary extensions of the human mind camp. I'm comfortable with the notion that conceptual connections can be facilitated by tools including, but not limited to mapping tools. I love the phrase visuo-spatial sketchpad of the human short-term memory, but that is only one aspect of learners' need for external devices.

Innovation, tool-use, collection, sorting, categorizing, storage and retrieval, even planning are basic tasks that humans and most animals exhibit. Technologies can be directed to participate in these tasks as well, and in some cases can do more better than individuals or groups. Making the connections seamless is surprisingly easy, as demonstrated by the sense-making and learning that is happening for hundreds, if not thousands of us in CCK08 over the last couple of months.

This is a precious gift. I want my students to have it. Now if they would look beyond its mouth...
.

Thursday, November 13, 2008

CCK08 - Shameless Commerce

One of the things that is emerging from the Connectivism discussion is that engaging media and video presentations have a place in higher education. To that end, most institutions are rushing to capture lectures and other presentations. Now they need hardware and software to do the capturing, uploading and distribution.

Enter NCast Telepresenter

NCast's Telepresenter™ Multi-media Capture Stations deliver high-resolution graphics plus high-definition video in an inexpensive appliance that requires no presenter interaction. Now you can create, stream, and record content like lectures, presentations, speeches, earnings calls, scientific events, and more - simply.

Take a look around and see why NCast has been chosen by the most demanding organizations to be their mixed-media production partner. NCast's Telepresenter™ - Simply Impressive

http://ncast.com/

This is a nice product from a local company. They have made a plug-and-play box that does it all - capture, encoding, FTP to the server, RSS feed generation. Unlike many of the other products, the NCast solution provides a single video file that includes audio and multiple video components, so there are no synchronization of problems on playback.

See actual video captured using the NCast equipment at Google Video - search for MIT Club of Northern California for the Science Lecture series

Explore the History and Fate of the Universe with MIT grad and Nobel Laureate Dr. George Smoot. As part of the Science Lecture Series, The MIT Club of Northern California is pleased to announce that Dr. George Smoot, SB ’66, PhD ’71, and Nobel Laureate ’06 will present a talk, ‘The History and Fate of the Universe’, to local Alumni on October 3rd 2007. Dr. Smoot, the second most famous Smoot to graduate from MIT, will present a lecture about his mapping of the cosmic background radiation. Initially discovered by Penzias and Wilson in the early 1960’s Dr. Smoot’s work led to the discovery and mapping of minute special variations in the cosmic background radiation. These variations on the order of 1 part in 100,000 represent quantum fluctuations in the structure of the known universe when it was less than the size of a proton. They are also the seeds from which present day galaxies have evolved. The analysis of these fluctuations provides a number of insights into both the history and the future evolution of the universe.

As more of these systems are deployed, there will be a lot more of video available. There is still something very compelling about seeing and hearing a Nobel Laureate telling jokes about cosmology.

.

Wednesday, November 12, 2008

CCK08 FOC08 - Tar Heel Reader

Everyone working with new readers needs to know about Tar Heel Reader.
Tar Heel Reader
Books for beginning readers of all ages

Welcome to the Tar Heel Reader, a collection of free, easy-to-read, and accessible books on a wide range of topics. Each book can be speech enabled and accessed using multiple interfaces (i.e. switches, alternative keyboards, touch screens, and dedicated AAC devices). The books may be downloaded as slide shows in PowerPoint, Impress, or Flash format.
http://tarheelreader.org/

I'm working with Grade 1-3 kids now. There are plenty of books already available. We will make more books together using the photos provided and our own word lists.

Tar Heel Reader is a wonderful resource for young adults. Lots of variety and many books are specifically provided for this age group. Having these kids author books as well as reading them is very engaging and challenging.

The authoring interface is easy to use and the resulting works are very "professional" looking. Beginning readers who build books will be very proud of their contributions. It is really exciting to know that people all over the world can read your book. If you and your learners are interested in building books as well as reading them, just request an invitation - this is how they are limiting spam and handling scaling the project.

This is what connectivism and online community mean to me.


Sunday, November 09, 2008

CCK08 Linker Taylor

When I was taking courses for my Masters in Education in 2000-2001, we had an assignment where we were required to pick a descriptive title and define a role that exemplified some important aspect of online teaching and learning.

I dubbed myself "Linker Taylor" because I have always been comfortable as the connector - someone who notices all sorts of odd bits of information, then finds opportunities to pass along the information in the most unlike situations.

tin.ker –noun
  • a mender of pots, kettles, pans, etc., usually an itinerant.
  • a person skilled in various minor kinds of mechanical work; jack-of-all-trades.
In the kids rhyme "tinker, tailor, ...begger-man, thief" - the tinker seems like the adventurer, good with things for productive ends.

Is this where the role of "teacher" is going? I hope so.
.

Monday, November 03, 2008

CCK08 I'm still here...

Today's CCK08 Daily includes a link to Ken's post, wondering if there is anyone else still out here. YES, I am! And enjoying the process.

My "participation" has changed and is changing. The CCK08 Daily makes it very easy to graze - interesting links and commentary appear in my inbox every morning so they are included in my morning skim and read along with the BBC news summary and Stephen's OLDaily. The summary is good and bad. It comes to me so I see it everyday. However, it somewhat limits the serendipity effect in that I'm not looking so broadly through a much bigger hopper of feeds.

I read some of the posts by fellow CCK08ers, either through the CCK08 Daily or the feeds that come through to Google Reader. Post titles are key to selecting what to read. If the title is provocative or slightly twisted, I'm there!

The feed of feeds is an interesting experience. Just dealing with the volume during those first couple of weeks was overwhelming. You could feel the frustration level of many participants. It was a bit like drinking from a fire hose. I suspect that had a significant filtering effect on the type of participants who continued to lurk and actively participate - aka Geoffrey Moore's crossing the chasm. Some of us gained new respect for feed readers with a flexible user interface that matches individual feed consumption preferences.

I usually read some or all of the weekly readings. If something moves me and I have time, I post to my own blog. If I comment on someone else's blog, I usually replicate that or make reference to it in my own blog. I bookmark most things that might be worth going back to and tag them as CCK08 in del.icio.us. I'm a digital pack rat, so I love knowing that these are just sitting there - all neatly tagged and formatted, until I come back for them.

The Moodle discussions content is too academic for my interests. It demonstrates that threaded discussions can be much better for actual discussions that individual blog entries with or without comments and links. Theory or not, I want to know what connectivism can do.

The live presentations are enjoyable and provide a sense of connectedness that comes with synchronous interaction. I join the live sessions when I can. I occasionally view the archived ones.

Though not actually producing the deliverables, I have been thinking about the assignments. For me personally, applying the learning to my courses is more helpful than writing an academic paper or creating a complex network diagram.

I'm also teaching a couple of online courses and subjecting students to some of this connectivism stuff. I'm a big believer in active learning and active research. There is some push back from students who are supposed to be that scarey NetGen. The literature suggests that they are going to demand that education change to be in line with their expertise with instant messaging, social surfing and multiplayer video games. I wish that it were so. We are having fun exploring the internet, Web 2.0 tools and learning in ways new to them. But as a group, they aren't the wired adventurers that I dream of guiding.

I really appreciate the collegiality of those still here. It is nice to come back to the warmth and companionship of the CCK08ers who are thinking and practicing connectivism. It is good to know that I'm not alone. Thanks to all!
..

Monday, October 27, 2008

CCK08 - student blogs

Students are working on community service learning projects. I had them set up blogs to be used to describe their work, report their weekly progress and reflect on the project's contribution to the community. Because community service learning is being added to many college requirements, this is an opportunity for the students engaged in community service learning to share their experience.

Interesting feedback from students. Blogging isn't something that they would choose to do. Setting up a blog was easy enough. It might be good for submitting certain assignments. Perhaps the discussions through comments would be interesting. However, using a blog as a record of progress as a student, was not viewed as important. Certainly not something that be considered an ePortfolio.

Don't students have any interest in preserving or sharing their writing assignments beyond the class? Aren't they proud of the work they have done and want others to have the benefit of their research, their experiences and ideas on these topics? Are the assignments not interesting enough for students to want to have a record of their effort once the course is completed? Are the assignment writing prompts seen as addressing issues that have no relevance beyond the class?

This is pretty disheartening. What are students learning and why if it isn't relevant beyond the assignments and the class? Are students so focused on getting an "A" that there is no value to work or by-products that do not directly contribute to improving their GPA? How did that happen? Why are we wasting all this talent and effort if there is nothing useful to be gained from it that benefits either the student or society?

Sunday, October 19, 2008

CCK08 Non-Linear Learning

There are many good relevant points in the article Developing Online From Simplicity toward Complexity: Going with the Flow of Non-Linear Learning. As a student, a parent and an educator, I have seen that the traditional linear lockstep-for-all teaching doesn't do justice to the potential of learners who are required to spend 12-20 years of their lives in this system.

Hooray! A new way of educational thinking and supporting learning!

Complexity theory attempts to explain the ‘big consequences of little - a recognition that the world is irreducibly complex, not determinist and predictable things’.

This is a wonderful characterization of complexity theory. Most of education and learning falls within this description. How many times have you "known" something really important that you happened to learn while doing something completely different? Happens all the time.

young people from across the globe, the ‘net generation’, are adopting remarkably similar learning approaches, characterised as chaotic, constructivist, integrated and multi-faceted, and where ‘play’ is central. These young, Lee claim, chart their own learning pathways, set their own goals, ‘learning’ is incidental and a sense of ‘fun’ is paramount. Amid such seeming chaos, these young people develop skills, beliefs and attitudes that many educators have been trying to foster in the school system for years; namely independent and self-directed learning.
... The non-linear approach, which moved away from pushing all students through the same content, produced a learning environment which was relevant and challenging for all students. By the latter cycles, students were more likely to be touched by a sense of ‘fun’ and ‘excitement’ in their computer use.

As much as I appreciate the fuss being made of how the net generation is so different, it isn't news. It is now fashionable in educational academia to address this perceived cataclysmic change that has come about in response to kids having access to the internet. The need has been there for a very long time. It just didn't get a lot of attention. Bring it on. Better late than never..

Friday, October 10, 2008

CCK08 Collectives and Findability

In the Wednesday October 8, CCK08 Elluminate session, Terry Anderson spoke about collectives as being different from groups and networks. I have always had the idea that there needs to be some mechanism or guide or agent - human or electronic, that would increase the likelihood of finding links or connections to appropriate - relevant, more or less complex related content. Collectives may have some applicability here.

Thanks to Judy Breck, "findability" is a new word in my vocabulary. I have long understood the concept, but I am delighted to discover there is a name for it and an active network of folks working on findability for open educational content.
.

CCK08 Deadheads are...

More on groups and networks
groups to me seek to summarise; whereas networks seek to aggregate. Groups set out to establish a singular vision, mission, or set of explicitly identified objectives to which all members are expected to adhere and conform. Networks devolve these concepts to the individual to decide, and the resulting reality for the entity is much more holistic and comprehensive. This is why it’s so much more difficult to define a network than a group.
...my comment

I’m with you - I don’t think Deadheads are a “group.” I do agree that there can be some pretty fine distinctions or interpretations, depending on one’s desire for tidy groups or messier networks. Now we have to mix in communities and collectives. And I haven’t heard mention of agents for many years - about time for that idea to reappear.

Have you heard from Stephen? He has strong sorting criteria for groups and networks - some I don’t fully understand where the differences apply in this case. What does he think?
Deadheads are…?
.

Sunday, October 05, 2008

CCK08 paper - Are we there yet?

I have been reading OLDaily for several years so I am familiar with
some of Stephen's thinking. As he frequently includes and comments on
the posts of George as well as other eduResearch notables like David
Wiley and Dave Cormier, much of what we are calling Connectivism isn't
new.

It has been interesting to participate in a MOOC. The potential of the
web for teaching and learning was evident from my earliest encounter.
Parvati Dev, the Director of SUMMIT - Stanford University Medical
School's group that was innovating in the use of all sorts of
technologies to support student learning, had access to the world wide
web and an early copy of Mozilla. This was in the spring of 1994. HTML
was easy for those of us with a programming background and experience
with other Markup Languages - GML, SGML. Add links to documents and
images anywhere on earth, and WOW!

The evolution from scientist-publishers to professional site
developers was a step backwards in some respects. When the web was
about scientists sharing research papers as text and graphs, so long
as the presentation was neat and readily available, everyone was
happy. The connections were there, and everyone got back to work with
access to information that would have taken years to access via the
traditional means of peer reviewed journals and academic conference
presentations. Then along came the marketing folks - it was all about
image and fancy formats and breathtakingly gorgeous splash screens.
Citizen publishing essentially disappeared for many years.

But all that has changed. We have social networks, blogs for all,
Fickr, Twitter, Digg and Second Life. But more importantly, we have
Wikipedia, OpenCourseware, Connexions and WikiEducator. Finally, we
are back on track to get some serious kick-ass learning going here.

While working on my Masters in Education (with a specialization in
Online Teacjing and Learning) at CSU East Bay (formerly known as CSU
Hayward), we reviewed a lot of learning theories. There are several
sites that list hundreds of these so the need for YALT
(yet-another-learning-theory) isn't a high priority. While I think it
is fine that lots of folks are having a lovely time in esoteric
arguments about the minutia, I'm just as happy to be running with the
little dogs who are off leveraging "it" - whatever Connectivism is,
and exploring practical applications and going out and building stuff.

The Connectivism course is both a learning experience and a dynamic
model of connectivism as I understand it. Lots of people are
connecting and learning. There is a general knowledge space - mostly
to do with education and learning, but brain science, psychology,
neural networking, management, academic administration, information
systems, learning management systems, instructional design, marketing,
communications, cool new technologies, and gaming all have their
places. This may be messy but it clearly demonstrated the ideas and
reality of Connectivism.

As someone who made it through the traditional education system, as
much by good fortune as anything, I am right out front helping to make
alternative learning experiences available to anyone and everyone who
is not well served by the current status quo in formal academic
education in North America today. It has been clear from the outset
that the internet provided the tools and infrastructure that could be
important elements to facilitating these changes when the time came.
It has taken surprisingly long for a critical mass to "get it" but now
we are on a roll, I think. Sure, there are many outstanding questions,
but they will be addressed in time. In the meantime, real progress is
being made on all fronts. Thanks to Stephen and George, as well as
Leigh, and the Dave's, and everyone involved in the Connectivism
movement.

What all of this demonstrates is that it really does take all kinds to
make a world. It is very exciting to be part of this adventure. It is
good to be working with literally hundreds of wonderful people who
care about the world and its people, who want to make communities
everywhere inclusive and empowering. It is great being part of the
solution called Connectivism.

Friday, September 26, 2008

CCK08 Connectivism and space

Speaking at the Commonwealth Club of California Sept 25, 2008 Frank Wilczek - Theoretical Physicist and Nobel Laureate 2004, said that space isn't empty. It is full of stuff whizzing abound and interacting. You may not see it but that is the really exciting thing.

Many lovely parallels with learning and connectivism...

During the CCK08 Ustream Sept 26 conversation today, Stephen describes clusters as stars and space, in response to George's centralization idea. These are both useful ideas and probably don't conflict, but don't talk about the same thing. There needs to be more discussion, particularly about clustering - intentional and purposeful, or not.

Tuesday, September 23, 2008

CCK08 FOC08 Eureka - Thanks, JSB

Memo to: John Seely Brown

As a long-time fan, I have learned many things from you. Today is no exception. Following a trail of crumbs from CCK08 to ecological environment got me here Learning, Working & Playing in the Digital Age ..John Seely Brown 1999

So we now have navigation being coupled to, basically, discovery and discovery being coupled to bricolage but you don't dare build on whatever you discover unless you can make a judgment concerning its quality or trustworthiness. Thus navigation, discovery, borrowing and judgment all get wrapped up together, especially when the student is engaged in using or building something that he deems important. Judgment is inherently more critical than ever in order to become an effective digital bricoleur.

I think this is a good summary of the complexity of what we are wrestling with in Connectivism and "the new learning" (something like "the new math" for those old enough to remember that one).

How I got here... ecological environment - interesting, need for additional terms - niches, meaning cues, action traces ... interrelations between communities, the environment and the culture left there by people - the traces of meanings (Llora, Yasui, Welge & Goldberg, 2006) and the traces of activities... JSB link, lurk, try

Saturday, September 20, 2008

CCK08 comment on blog post / FOC08 open vs closed communities

Darn it. I see a really interesting partial post by Nellie on Generosity - someone I greatly admire and who's great effort in organizing the WikiEducator Council election should be recognized and celebrated. And, bang - sorry you can't read the whole post or add a comment.

This leads to some thinking, and I hope, some further discussion about making and breaking connections (CCK08). And open / closed communities (FOC08). What's in it for me? If I block comments utilizing the provided screening devices, then I don't have to deal with the spam and annoying poor connectivism hygiene of others.

In a community where the primary communication is via discussion forums, there is the problem of the Commons - in a large open discussion, everyone is a user or a guest and no one assumes responsible for the ongoing sustainability of the resource. They post what they want, even if it means others are turned off by the frequency and/or tone of their posting. We have seen this to some extent in the CCK08 course in the Moodle discussions. A more closely held, closed community is better at dealing with this format. All participants accept and share responsibility.

Well, yes but... Houshuang says "I really want my research to be available to everyone ... approval is taking too long, so I am also publishing the files here on my blog. ... Creative Commons BY license. I am eager that as many people as possible that would be interested in this topic are able to come across it, so feel free to share it with others that are interested. I am also very happy to receive feedback and other perspectives"

This may be representative of most blogging - intended as primary personal statements, observations and links to other information of interest. A community that is built around blogs can be very open and inclusive as each member controls their own space within the community. In FOC08 and the blogs associated with CCK08, the openness is clearly a benefit. There have been protests from the community when registration is required to view and/or comment on blog entries. Openness is not only desirable, but expected, at least among the blog commenting participants in CCK08.

Returning to Nellie's post on Generosity, I actually have a Ning account and reluctantly logged in to read the post and comment. I wouldn't do this for just anyone. Nellie is very special.

Wednesday, September 17, 2008

FOC08 / CCK08 double-dipping - Community Blogging

Stephen - again talks about Community Blogging. I read this article when it was first posted, but I didn't understand too much of it then. Little did I know, that it would be back. Thanks. I really enjoyed it this time, as I nod my head in agreement.

This week I have been in meetings and presentations about student civic engagement and community service learning. I was astonished how often the words "connections" and "networks" came up in the discussions. Although most references were more general, it was good to hear that there is an interest and awareness of these ideas in community colleges.